The International Service on Human Rights (ISHR) has released a new handbook on NGO access to the UN and the UN Committee on NGOs. The case of IDSN, whose application for UN consultative (ECOSOC) status has been unjustly deferred by the Committee for 7 years, is featured prominently in the book. An event to launch the book was held in Geneva where the IDSN Executive Director spoke on a panel alongside the ISHR and the Vice-President of the Human rights council.
The handbook, A Practical Guide to the UN Committee on NGOs, is an honest account of the way in which the NGO committee functions and malfunctions, with helpful tips and useful insight. At the well-attended launch, hosted by the Permanent Mission of Australia to the UN in Geneva on 22 April, the Vice-President of the Human Rights Council said,
“The effective and active participation of NGOs in the Human Rights Council and its mechanisms is instrumental. We simply cannot fulfil the Council’s mandate without them … Yet, what is worrisome is the fact that according to the UN Special Rapporteur on Human Rights Defenders in his report to the HRC’s 27th session, several stakeholders have voiced concerns about the large number of deferrals and perceived lack of transparency in decisions on consultative status of NGOs.”
Eleanor Openshaw of the ISHR commented that the NGO Committee is failing its mandate because it discriminates against human rights organisations when processing the applications. Organisations working on issues such as LGBT and caste were often excluded. Ms. Openshaw suggested that host states of organisations blocked by the NGO Committee should be more active in supporting the NGOs in question and that harassment of NGOs by the NGO Committee should be considered a reprisal, to be included in the report of the UN Secretary-General.
Swiss human rights expert and member of the ISHR Board, Jean-Daniel Vigny, also spoke at the launch suggesting the set-up of an international campaign to make more NGO friendly states join the Committee and introducing a 3-year limit to how long an application may be deferred in the NGO Committee.
IDSN Executive Director, Rikke Nöhrlind, presented the case of unjust deferral of IDSN’s application for ECOSOC status through the perpetual questioning from India for over 7 years saying that the denial of consultative status is blocking the work of IDSN at the UN and that IDSN’s application is the longest ever deferred by the Committee.
IDSN’s case and the issue of caste is also featured several places in the handbook and as a case study in chapter 5. The handbook highlights the statements of the UN Special Rapporteur on the exercise of the rights to freedom of peaceful assembly and of association, Maina Kiai, both in his report to the General Assembly (GA) and in his statement at the GA, where he criticized India for arbitrarily blocking the International Dalit Solidarity Network (IDSN) from obtaining UN consultative status calling it, “clearly unacceptable, wrong and unfair.”
Marta Mauras, Ambassador of Chile to the UN in Geneva and former Vice-Chair of the UN Committee on the Rights of the Child also spoke on the panel stating that,
“Too often we see objections presented year after year in the NGO Committee in the form of questions that challenge NGO applicants for ECOSOC consultative status … we believe the system needs strengthening by ensuring the UN is a space that guarantees the right to freedom of expression of ideas and opinions.”
More information:
Download the Practical Guide to the UN Committee on NGOs.
IDSN’s 7-year struggle for ECOSOC accreditation
Excerpts on IDSN and caste from the handbook
Remarks of the Presidency of the UN Human Rights Council at the launch of the Guide
Remarks of Chile’s Ambassador to the UN in Geneva at the launch of the Guide
Remarks of Swiss human rights expert Jean-Daniel Vigny at the launch of the Guide
IDSN News: US urged to actively support IDSN’s application for UN consultative status
IDSN News: India called out at the UN General Assembly for blocking IDSN’s consultative status
IDSN News: Special Rapporteur highlights unwarranted deferral of IDSN’s UN ECOSOC accreditation
Twitter reporting:
. @idsnupdates take part in Great panel to discuss #NGOaccess to the UN http://t.co/cZ1bh03xob with @ISHRglobal @AustraliaUN_GVA
— IDSN (@idsnupdates) April 22, 2015
. @idsnupdates case featured in the new @ISHRglobal handbook on the NGO Committee https://t.co/5hYuTJJ8Yw
— IDSN (@idsnupdates) April 22, 2015
Participants at @AustraliaUN_GVA event see new @ISHRglobal handbook on ECOSOC #NGOCte as important contribution to enhance #NGOaccess to UN
— ISHR (@ISHRglobal) April 22, 2015
Our application to #NGOCte has been the longest ever deferred, by questions asked by only one State, #India says @idsnupdates #NGOaccess
— ISHR (@ISHRglobal) April 22, 2015
The denial of consultative status to @idsnupdates effectively blocks our work on caste discrimination at #UN says #RikkeNohrlind #NGOaccess
— ISHR (@ISHRglobal) April 22, 2015
NGO Cte fails in its mandate bc. it discriminates against human rights orgs. in approach to applications says @eleanoropenshaw #NGOaccess
— ISHR (@ISHRglobal) April 22, 2015
Host states of organizations blocked by NGO Cte should more actively support NGOs from their territories says @eleanoropenshaw #NGOaccess
— ISHR (@ISHRglobal) April 22, 2015
Harassment of NGOs through #NGOCte should be considered as a #reprisal & incl in @secgen report says @eleanoropenshaw #NGOaccess
— ISHR (@ISHRglobal) April 22, 2015
#HRCPres: Share @MainaKiai_UNSR concerns about large number of deferrals of NGO applications for consultative status w/ ECOSOC #NGOaccess
— ISHR (@ISHRglobal) April 22, 2015
Civil society is at the core of human rights & at of work of the Human Rights Council says #HRCPres at #NGOaccess event @AustraliaUN_GVA
— ISHR (@ISHRglobal) April 22, 2015
US should take strong stand against caste-discrimination and support @idsnupdates at UN http://t.co/xAYelHMyQK @AmbassadorPower
— ISHR (@ISHRglobal) March 25, 2015