In statements at the UN Racism Conference yesterday states and NGOs put caste discrimination on the agenda, while India objected
Geneva, April 24, 2009 (IDSN) — Despite caste-discrimination being left out of the official programme and the final outcome document at the Durban Review Conference, states and NGOs spoke out strongly on the issue in statements at the conference yesterday.
Nepal spoke with great concern about the many problems associated with inhumane “untouchability” practices, resulting from caste discrimination in Nepal, and alongside Slovenia, Pakistan, Bangladesh and Mauritius put the issue back on the conference agenda. India, who has a history of considering caste discrimination an internal issue, objected strongly to the issue of caste being brought up at this conference. Meanwhile, there are at least 170 million victims of caste discrimination in India alone and 260 million globally.
In a similar vein, Justice B.C. Patel of the National Human Rights Commission in India spoke out at a side event on caste discrimination earlier in the week, referring to caste issues in India as internal issues which should be dealt with as ‘family affairs’. This statement was strongly objected to by the many Dalits (victims of caste discrimination) present at the event, who feel nothing is being done to implement laws and stop discrimination at the local level.
Following the statements yesterday, a large group of Asian and international NGO’s issued a statement saying, “We strongly reject the argument that caste-based discrimination is an ‘internal affair’ which should not be addressed by relevant UN mechanisms, including this Review Conference.”
At a press conference, Co-ordinator of the International Dalit Solidarity Network, Rikke Nöhrlind pointed out that victims of caste based discrimination suffer a hidden apartheid of segregation, modern-day slavery and other forms of discrimination, stating that “This issue has been skilfully hidden by certain governments and Dalits are simply being treated as lesser human beings and denied justice.”
India has objected to caste being associated to the issue of race and while the group of NGOs comment in their statement that caste is not the same as race, they contend that it results in similar manifestations as reaffirmed by the Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination (CERD) in its General Recommendation 29.
“Caste discrimination is a major global human rights issue, that needs to be effectively dealt with at the international level,” Clive Baldwin, senior legal advisor at Human Rights Watch commented in a press release. “As the UN racial discrimination committee has made perfectly clear, caste discrimination falls under the Race Convention, and thereby within the scope of this review conference.”
In a press conference earlier this week UN High Commissioner for Human Rights Navi Pillay said that the conference was about racism, racial discrimination, xenophobia and related intolerance, and she personally felt that “related intolerance” would cover issues of caste, class and social status. Ms. Pilay has also spoken out strongly against caste discrimination in her visits to India and Nepal in March.
Despite these assertions, caste discrimination was left out completely of the final outcome document of the conference. Commenting on this Paul Divakar of the National Campaign for Dalit Human Rights (NCDHR) in India, said that officially, “This Durban Review Conference has totally eliminated any mention of caste or discrimination based on work and descent, despite including text on similar groups such as the Romas”
CONTACTS & RESOURCES
PRESS CONTACT: Please do not hesitate to contact email@example.com mb_@If you can read this, please upgrade to a modern browser.idsn.orgor +45 61701218 for further information on the topic, relevant documents, case studies or interviews with Dalit representatives.
For an immediate interview contact:
Paul Divakar, the National Campaign for Dalit Human Rights (NCDHR), +41 787392726 available from 14-17 for telephone interviews
Rikke Nöhrlind, Co-ordinator, International Dalit Solidarity Network, +45 29700630 available from 12-16 for telephone interviews.
NOTES FOR EDITORS
- Caste discrimination is any distinction, exclusion, restriction, or preference based on inherited status such as work and descent, commonly originating from a division of society into castes or social categories. This chronic human rights condition, which is associated with the notion of impurity, pollution and practices of ‘untouchability’, involves massive violations of civil, political, economic, social and cultural rights. It is estimated that 260 million people are affected by caste discrimination worldwide.
- The Durban Review Conference is being held in Geneva between 20-24 April 2009 with the purpose of reviewing the implementation of the Durban Declaration and Programme of Action (DDPA).
- The Durban Declaration and Plan of Action (DDPA) includes several provisions relevant in the fight against this form of discrimination, and several UN bodies, in particular the United Nations Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination (CERD), have repeatedly reaffirmed that caste falls under the Race Convention.
- Several UN bodies have furthermore reaffirmed that discrimination based on work and descent – the UN terminology for caste discrimination – is prohibited by international human rights law, and that it is a global human rights phenomenon which should be addressed comprehensively through existing human rights mechanisms.
- Human Rights Watch has also previously highlighted the need for tackling the causes and consequences of this kind of discrimination by, among other things, encouraging delegations to welcome the work carried out by CERD on discrimination based on descent, to review CERD’s General Comment No. 29 on Descent, and to include reference to it as a guiding opinion in defining and combating descent-based discrimination.
Photos and Interviews:
- Press Kit: includes an overview of the issues, a list of relevant events and interview profiles for the many Dalit representatives travelling to Geneva to raise their voices on behalf of the millions of victims of caste based discrimination. Many of these representatives are also available for interviews during the conference, and for interviews after the conference in their own countrie
- Contact IDSN on +45 61701218 or firstname.lastname@example.org for photos – we have a good stock of high quality photos of Dalits in India taken by award winning photographer Jakob Carlsen – available for licensing from the photographer. For examples please see the online exhibition.
- The IDSN website – www.idsn.org provides a wide range of resources and material on the topic of caste-discrimination including case studies, video materials, and research materials. For more information on the Durban Review Conference please see the overview on the IDSN website.
- Contact IDSN on +45 61701218 or email@example.com for more information on the topic.
THIS PRESS RELEASE HAS BEEN RELEASED JOINTLY BY Human Rights Watch, Lutheran World Federation, Pax Romana, IMADR, International Dalit Solidarity Network (IDSN), NCDHR, and FORUM-ASIA